What are the most important benefits you expect to get from the best ice fishing boots you can find?
This should be an easy question to answer. When you are taking part in any activity when the temperature is cold, and there’s ice/water involved, you need to find footwear that keeps your feet warm and dry. So, “warm” and “dry” are the two most important factors to consider when you’re searching for ice fishing boots.
Manufacturers have taken these two elements into account, naturally, and construct their boots so your feet are comfortable when you’re on the ice. So, how do you choose a pair? What details do you focus on if most of the boots do what they’re supposed to do?
In other words, how do you separate the “good” footwear from what are truly the best ice fishing boots?
That’s the purpose of this article and these reviews. Take a closer look at some of the most popular boots. They are popular because they do the job they’re designed for. You may find some specific details of each product that make them more suitable for you, so this will help you make your decision. You may also find some with a slightly lower price than a similar boot. Of course, this will also help you make the right decision.
Click to View Post Navigation
- 1 What Makes the Best Ice Fishing Boots?
- 2 6 Best Ice Fishing Boots 2018 – Reviews and Comparison
- 2.1 1. Baffin Men’s Endurance Snow Boot – Best Overall and Snow Protection
- 2.2 2. IceArmor Boots
- 2.3 3. Bobcat K Zip Insulated Boot
- 2.4 4. Baffin Apex Men’s Extreme Winter Boots – Best Extreme Conditions Boot
- 2.5 5. Helly Hansen Cold-Weather Boot
- 2.6 6. Irish Setter Elk Tracker 860 – Best Traditional Style
- 3 Conclusion
What Makes the Best Ice Fishing Boots?
All the questions presented in the brief introduction can be distilled into the question posed in the title of this section. Quality construction is essential, so the boots don’t leak when the outside gets wet. You also need to find a boot that provides sufficient insulation, without making the foot too hot. Too much heat can end up being uncomfortable, though it’s not as much a problem as having seriously cold feet when you’re out on the ice.
Some shoppers prefer boots with a removable insulation layer, so they can be worn in different weather conditions. This will be a detail you may want to consider, though you have to take care not to get a boot that is so bulky they aren’t comfortable for walking, or for sitting while you’re waiting for the fish to bite.
When you’re searching for the best ice fishing boots, you’ll need to look for strong seams, which keep the water out, and you’ll also need to look for details such as the material used for the sole. The design of the sole will also be important since you may need traction when walking on slippery surfaces.
In general, you should find footwear that will keep your feet comfortable even when the temperature drops well below the freezing-temperature level.
6 Best Ice Fishing Boots 2018 – Reviews and Comparison
|Model||Upper Material||Sole Material||Our Score|
|Baffin Men’s Endurance Snow Boot||Fabric||Rubber||4.7|
|Bobcat K Zip Insulated Boot||Leather||Rubber||4.5|
|Baffin Apex Men’s Extreme Winter Boots||Leather||Rubber||4.7|
|Helly Hansen Cold-Weather Boot||Leather, Textile||Synthetic||4.8|
|Irish Setter Elk Tracker 860||Leather||Synthetic||4.9|
1. Baffin Men’s Endurance Snow Boot – Best Overall and Snow Protection
Many veterans of the outdoor world consider Baffin the only choice for quality footwear, when cold weather and tough conditions are standard. The Endurance Snow Boot is available in different colors and has a durable rubber sole for excellent traction and added insulation from the cold. The boot shaft is high, at almost 15 inches.
Your feet benefit from the 8-layer, removable inner boot layer. This boot is designed to extend to mid-calf, has taped-seams for added protection, and offers an extendable cuff and lace-lock design. The boot also has a handy pull strap and a convenient pocket at the ankle. Great boot for slipping on and off when you need to shovel snow or walk through the snow to get to your vehicle.
This footwear is not going to be the most comfortable for regular wear or driving the car, simply because they are a bit bulky. But if you want to protect your feet and be comfortable in the coldest of temperatures, the Endurance is probably the one for you.
If you want to put on one of the most-popular, durable boots for ice fishing and cold-temperature activity, the Ice Armor Onyx boot could be for you. Your feet will be comfortable and dry even in extreme temperatures. This boot is lightweight and breathable, while remaining waterproof. Depend on the Thinsulate lining for great warmth and the rugged sole for traction on ice.
You may also want to go with the Sub Zero line from Ice Armor. This series is also designed for extreme weather conditions, and are especially good for ice fishing because their lightweight and durable. As with the Onyx line, they use Thinsulate to keep your feet warm.
This winter boot delivers comfort and good fit, with easy-on and easy-off thanks to a zipper that stands up to the test. Bobcat’s K Zip boot has a leather upper, with added comfort due to the expansion darts of neoprene.
The Thinsulate/wool combination liner is sewn in and provides excellent protection for ice fishing and most other outdoor activities, including winter hiking.
Oil-tanned leather is part of the 10-inch shaft. This boot also features a durable, lugged sole for great traction and added insulation from cold ground or ice.
4. Baffin Apex Men’s Extreme Winter Boots – Best Extreme Conditions Boot
No list of best ice fishing boots would be complete without a second entry from one of the leading suppliers in the industry.
Baffin Apex boots are an excellent choice for keeping your feet warm when you’re going to be in cold conditions for an extended period. The design keeps them from being too bulky, so you can hike in them, relax when ice fishing.
But, you can also depend on them if you are in deep snow, since they’re made to keep your feet dry as well. They offer a 14-inch height, which includes a leather-like material for comfort. If you want to spend just a bit more on the right pair of winter boots, this could be your choice.
The Helly Hansen series of cold-weather boots includes the Garibaldi 2 and the Skage, to mention just a couple of options from this popular company. The toe and heel caps on the Skage are real leather, which provides extra protection from the cold. The Garibaldi is made with a combination of leather and synthetic material, with mid-calf height and faux-fur lining.
The tongue and collar are padded for comfort and you get good traction with the lugged rubber sole. Great protection and insulation properties make these a good choice for ice fishing and for other winter activities.
6. Irish Setter Elk Tracker 860 – Best Traditional Style
What do you get when you buy Irish Setter Elk Tracker boots? A leather boot with synthetic, lugged sole for great traction and GORE-TEX lining.
This is marketed as a lace-up leather hunting boot, but it’s also water proof, so it should serve you well for ice fishing as well, thanks to insulation from Thinsulate Ultra.
This is a versatile boot, because it will serve equally well for hikers, fishermen, and hunters. They are very comfortable and are available in extra-wide so you can wear heavier socks if you prefer. You’ll find they’re very comfortable for all-day wear. You’ll have plenty of support with the steel shank and the 12-inch height.
As mentioned from the beginning, you should be looking for good quality in your ice fishing boots, especially when it comes to foot warmth and keeping your feet dry. Durability is very important since you’ll be wearing this footwear in less-than-ideal conditions. Spend a bit extra for the best insulation and if you want to wear these boots in warmer weather, you should select removable liners.
It’s also important to look closely at the sole design, since you’re going to need excellent traction for ice and snow. You should also look for handles and straps that will make the boots easier to put on and take off. Cushioned mid-sole and ankle height are two more key factors to consider.
These reviews cover some of the most-popular boots, based on sales figures. But these options are also presented as some of the smart choices for warmth and comfort when ice fishing or walking in the snow. While you should definitely look for great insulation, you should also pay attention to flexibility and ankle fit, for comfort reasons.
You can select leather uppers from a top manufacturer like Irish Setter, or you can get the synthetic uppers from top makers like Baffin. Either will serve the purpose, though one might be best for “regular” wear while the other would be best for more extreme conditions. Removal liners are a good choice, as mentioned, as is easy lacing. Don’t hesitate to buy your boots a bit wider or longer so you can wear thick socks.
Look at the extra cuff on the Baffin if you’re going to be in deeper snow. Your ankles and feet will appreciate it. Fastening your boots is important as well. Easy lacing has been mentioned, but you might also consider zipper operation. Color and overall design won’t be key factors to most people, though some of the best boots do come in two or three colors. Women’s models also have faux fur around the top, for an added touch.
Some ice-fishermen choose the old style rubber boots, which can be fine for keeping the feet dry. But they may not serve you well when the temperatures drop. You can have both “warm” and “dry” but you will probably have to spend a few extra dollars. In the long run, the investment will pay off in comfort.